Publicist Matt Polk said Creel died at his home in Manhattan of metastatic melanotic peripheral nerve sheath sarcoma. He was diagnosed in July 2024.
Creel had a knack for Golden Age Broadway revivals, but he also performed in modern fare like the role of Dr Pomatter in Sara Bareilles’ musical Waitress on Broadway in 2019 and on the West End in 2020.
He won an Olivier Award for The Book Of Mormon.
Gavin Creel accepts the award for Hello, Dolly! (Michael Zorn/Invision/AP)
Composer and playwright Lin-Manuel Miranda recalled that Creel was his first King George III when the soon-to-be-smash Hamilton was being workshopped: “He wrapped the audience around his finger with nothing but a Burger King crown and his mind-blowing charisma and talent. He is so loved and it is unimaginable that he’s no longer with us.”
Creel was raised in Findlay, Ohio, and graduated from the University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre & Dance.
He toured and did regional work before landing the breakout role of Jimmy Smith, opposite then-fellow newcomer Sutton Foster, in the Broadway production of Thoroughly Modern Millie.
He also worked on Stephen Sondheim’s penultimate musical, Bounce, directed by Hal Prince.
He played Jean-Michel in the revival of “La Cage Aux Folles” in 2004 and returned to Broadway in 2009 as Claude Hooper Bukowski in the Public Theatre’s revival of Hair.
The Associated Press’ critic Michael Kuchwara was full of praise: “Gavin Creel, besides possessing a powerhouse voice, brings a sweet-tempered poignancy to Claude, the most anguished member of the tribe.
“It’s Claude who has the most back story in the show: a conventional, middle-class upbringing in Queens; a total fascination with all things British, expressed in the song Manchester, England; and an uneasy sense of duty that eventually gets him drafted and into the Vietnam War. Creel handles it all with assurance.”
He played Steven Kodaly in the 2016 production of She Loves Me at Studio 54. The following season, Creel was tapped for the role of Cornelius Hackl, opposite legends Bette Midler and David Hyde Pierce, in the smash 2017 revival of Hello, Dolly! directed by Jerry Zaks.
Creel became a primary voice within the theatre industry by working to pass the federal Marriage Equality Act. He teamed up with friends Rory O’Malley and Jenny Kanelos to co-found the non-profit organisation Broadway Impact.
Offstage, he played the singing waiter Bill in the films Eloise At The Plaza and Eloise At Christmastime alongside Dame Julie Andrews.
In 2021, he was cast in Ryan Murphy’s miniseries American Horror Stories opposite Matt Bomer. His 2022 solo concert was filmed for the premiere episode of PBS’s Stars Onstage At Westport Country Playhouse.
In 2022, Creel was cast in an off-Broadway concert production of Sondheim and James Lapine’s fractured fairy tale musical Into The Woods” – Creel played the roles of Cinderella’s Prince as well as the Wolf.
The show later transferred to Broadway and was extended multiple times, earning a Tony nomination for best revival of a musical.
He is survived by his mother, Nancy Clemens Creel, and father, James William Creel; his sisters, Heather Elise Creel and Allyson Jo Creel; and his partner, Alex Temple Ward.